Philoponus argumentation is analytically examined and explained, its premises brought to light and its conclusions evaluated. It was here that simplicius massive programme of commentary on aristotle preserved many ancient texts and teachings from the milineum of greek philosophy preceding his time which otherwise would have been lost. Of the commentary on the metaphysics that is transmitted under his name, only the first five books are regarded as genuine. The thomas aquinas commentary on the metaphysics of aristotle. Commentary on aristotles physics aristotelian commentary. Widely considered to be one of the most important works written on philosophy, aristotles nicomachean ethics is separated into 10 books that cover topics such as friendship, happiness, and the invaluable virtues that a person should strive to obtain. Change receives two definitions in chapters 1 and 2, as involving the actualisation of the potential or of the changeable. Called the master of those who know, by dante, his influence on the history of thought and knowledge is unparalleled. Commentary on aristotles physics by aquinas, thomas and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at. Alexander wrote commentaries on most of aristotles treatises. Averroes offers a more literal type of commentary on aristotles works, especially in his long commentaries, which are considered to have been composed after his short and middle commentaries.
He quotes at length from melissus, parmenides and zeno, sometimes from their original works but also from later writers from plato onwards, drawing particularly on alexanders lost commentary on aristotles physics and on porphyry. Aristotle moves on to the question of the infinite for spatial magnitudes, motion and time. He also denies aristotles view that motion would be impossible in a vacuum. Socrates had inquired about the nature of things, such as piety, and plato had claimed that the nature of things is their form. This collection offers, as the seriesdescription of the cambridge critical guides promises, cuttingedge research on the physics, one of aristotles most fundamental and influential works.
It offers explanations of thomass intention in writing the work expositio in libros physicorum, thomass view of the composition of physics and the weaknesses of aristotles argument as identified by thomas. Change enters into the very definition of nature as an internal source of change. Aristotle claims that in a chain of efficient causes, where the first element of the series acts through the intermediary of the other items, it is the first member in the causal chain, rather than the intermediaries, which is the moving cause physics 8. He quotes at length from melissus, parmenides and zeno, sometimes from their original works but also from later writers from plato onwards, drawing particularly on alexanders lost commentary on aristotle s physics and on porphyry. These books therefore form a natural entry into aristotles system as a whole, and also occupy an. It is a collection of treatises or lessons that deal with the most general philosophical principles of natural or moving things, both living and nonliving, rather than physical theories in the modern sense or investigations of the particular contents of the universe. In the commentary on physics 4, 69, by contrast, he explicitly ridicules aristotles dynamics and introduces his rival theory of impetus, applying it to the motion of projectiles and comets. This writing he had always seen as embodying many of aristotle s most enduring insights. The article deals with the oldest criticism of anaximanders monism, for which we have evidence, found in john philoponus commentary on the first book of aristotles physics. It contains his attack on atomism which forced subsequent greek and islamic atomists to reshape their views entirely.
The commentary on aristotle s physics is a voluminous work. This comprises not just physics in the modern sense, but all things in the world so to use modern phraseology aristotle views the study of nature to. Thomas aquinass commentary on aristotles physics by. Aristotles physics was the essential starting point for anyone. The annenberg cpbproject provided support for entering this text. How could something come to be pale from being musical, unless musical were a coincident of the notpale or dark thing.
This new english version of the physics is the last contribution to the understanding of greek thought of richard hope, long a teacher of philosophy at the university of pittsburgh. The fine editions of the aristotelian commentary series make available long outofprint commentaries of st. In this volume simplicius is dealing with aristotle s account of the presocratics, and for many of them he is our chief or even sole authority. Charlton represents a specific, individual, material embodiment of a distinct intellectual or artistic creation found in boston university libraries. In this commentary on aristotle physics book eight, chapters one to five, the sixthcentury philosopher simplicius quotes and explains important fragments of the presocratic philosophers, provides the fragments of his christian opponent philoponus against aristotle on the eternity of the world, and makes extensive use of the lost commentary of. Aristotle, as an antireductionist, believes that all such attempts fail. An essay is presented on theologian saint thomas aquinass commentary on the work physics by philosopher aristotle. He was among the pagan philosophers persecuted by justinian in the early 6th century, and was forced for a time to seek refuge in the persian.
Aristotles physics was the essential starting point for anyone who wished to study the natural sciences. From this perspective, i take the liberty to summarize aristotles physics using a modern terminology whenever possible. He studied under plato at athens and taught there 367347. Alexander wrote commentaries on most of aristotle s treatises. After he died, aristotles books, which represent perhaps just onethird of.
In the space available i cannot begin to do justice to, but can. Physics book i the ingredients of change comingtobe 1. This collection offers, as the seriesdescription of the cambridge critical guides promises, cuttingedge research on the physics, one of aristotle s most fundamental and influential works. Whether the infinite exists, and what it is are closely related to motion historically because of the philosophers who have treated it, and so aristotle claims they should be treated here. Commentators on aristotle stanford encyclopedia of philosophy.
The commentators ancient commentators on aristotle. Physics by aristotle, part of the internet classics archive. Naturalism, however, as opposed to a sacral vision of the world, was penetrating all realms. There has recently been considerable renewed interest in book 7 of the physics of aristotle, once regarded as merely an undeveloped forerunner to book 8. Bekker numbers have been added to passages from the politics. Commentaries on aristotle refers to the great mass of literature produced, especially in the ancient and medieval world, to explain and clarify the works of aristotle. In the first two books of the physics aristotle discusses philosophical issues involved in the investigation of the physical universe. According to aristotle products produced by the crafts inasmuch as they are products of the crafts. In this volume simplicius is dealing with aristotles account of the presocratics, and for many of them he is our chief or even sole authority. Much of his approach is just scholarly, but in places he reveals his neoplatonist affiliation and attempts to show the basic agreement among his predecessors in spite of their. Thomas, crossreferenced using an easily accessible mode of referring to aristotle in the commentary. Perfect for acing essays, tests, and quizzes, as well as for writing lesson plans. Jan 15, 2002 for his physics and astronomy, aristotle has become identified as the barrier to scientific progress in the renaissance.
The internet classics archive physics by aristotle. The pupils of aristotle were the first to comment on his writings, a tradition which was continued by the peripatetic school throughout the hellenistic period and the roman era. Aristotle lays out his plan for the physics, though it will only become apparent at the end of the book for the firsttime reader. The basic idea in book one is to find out the number. Aristotles physics book i chapter i argument continued. Then, both in cases of natural generation and artificial production, it. Physica, or physicae auscultationes discusses concepts including. Offering the first complete translation into modern english of aquinas unfinished commentary on aristotles politics, this translation follows the definitive leonine text of aquinas and reproduces in english those passages of william of moerbekes exacting yet elliptical translation of the politics from which aquinas worked. Physics is a treatise by aristotle in which he deals with the study of nature, or rather, how we should study nature. As far as i know, this is the first collection of essays devoted to the physics to appear since the one edited by lindsay judson 25 years ago.
Metaphysics, 14 books on what aristotle called first philosophy, the study of absolute being, dealing with such things as being in itself and the ultimate grounds of being, the relation of matter and form, causation material, formal, efficient, and final causes, and the prime mover. Mary of the springs, columbus, ohio 19581962 html edition by joseph kenny, o. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Contraries in chapter 5, aristotle argues that change involves contraries. The debate surrounding the importance of the text is not new to modern scholarship. In this commentary on aristotle physics book eight, chapters one to five, the sixthcentury philosopher simplicius quotes and explains important fragments of the presocratic philosophers, provides the fragments of his christian opponent philoponus against aristotle on the eternity of the world, and makes extensive use of the lost commentary of aristotle s leading defender, alexander of. But aristotle would say that it is the only way to understand the regularity and apparent purposiveness of natural processes.
This comprises not just physics in the modern sense, but all things in the world so to use modern phraseology aristotle views the study of nature to be the domain of physics, biology, even psychology. For one swallow does not make a summer, nor does one day. Physics 350 bc one of aristotles treatises on natural science. One might think that this provides him with a definition of change, since it seems to. The only alternative is a mechanistic explanation of the world, such as was attempted by some of the presocratics. Therefore the long commentary on the physics will serve as my basis for examining averroes understanding of nature. A study of saint thomas commentary on the eight books of aristotle s physics by j a mcwilliams. Below are some shorter introductions and bibliographical pointers. Much of his approach is just scholarly, but in places he reveals his neoplatonist. This is the first complete translation since 1930 of aristotles key work on science. Learn exactly what happened in this chapter, scene, or section of aristotle 384322 b.
In his translations, hope attempted to have them make sense to the english reader, and above all to make philosophic. Some books like the ethics and the methaphysics were great, but others, especially the posterior analytics were terribly boring. Aristotle 384322 bc one of the most prominent greek philosophers, he is said to have reflected on every subject which came within the range of ancient thought. This writing he had always seen as embodying many of aristotles most enduring insights. Rowan translation of the william of moerbeke latin translation of the metaphysics of aristotle. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Aristotles physics by aquinas abebooks shop for books. This collection of ten new essays by leading aristotelian scholars examines a wide range of issues in the physics and related works, including method, causation and explanation, chance, teleology, the infinite, the nature of time, the critique of atomism, the role of mathematics in. Over two thousand years ago aristotle s investigation i. Commentators on aristotle stanford encyclopedia of. Aristotle details his physics mostly in three books.
For his physics and astronomy, aristotle has become identified as the barrier to scientific progress in the renaissance. For information about the ancient commentators on aristotle a good place to start online is with the helpful entries in the stanford encyclopedia of philosophy, and of those the best place to begin is the entry on commentators on aristotle by andrea falcon. Aristotle, great greek philosopher, researcher, reasoner, and writer, born at stagirus in 384 bce, was the son of nicomachus, a physician, and phaestis. Commentary on aristotle s physics by thomas aquinas books iii translated by richard j. His commentaries on the prior analytics book 1, the topics, the meteorology, and on sense perception have survived. On aristotle physics 6 book six of aristotles physics, which concerns the continuum, shows aristotle at his best. It is a series of eight books that deal with the general bases and. He introduces his distinction between form and matter and his fourfold classification of causes or explanatory factors, and defends teleological explanation.
227 224 1264 1201 1056 1287 204 620 910 610 1347 1349 537 769 1324 1051 17 642 309 242 1293 1031 985 109 1163 810 1459 1313 727 1309 526 995 915